What the Black-Scholes model is actually doing
The Black-Scholes model treats an option as a contract whose value depends on the relationship between the current underlying price and the strike price, adjusted for time remaining, volatility, interest rates, and dividends. Those inputs are combined to produce a theoretical premium for a call and a put under a specific set of assumptions.
That theoretical premium is not a promise of where an option will trade. Real markets can price options above or below model value because of supply, demand, liquidity, discrete dividends, American-style exercise features, or volatility assumptions that do not match the model’s simplifications. The value of the model is that it gives investors a disciplined baseline for comparing option prices and risk sensitivities.