Why there is more than one ideal weight formula
There is no single universal ideal body weight equation. The best-known methods, including Devine, Hamwi, Robinson, and Miller, were developed from historical height-weight tables or later refinements of those tables. That is why an ideal weight calculator by height often shows several answers instead of only one number.
In practice, these formulas are most useful as comparison tools. They give a rough reference point based on height and sex, but they do not directly account for body composition, frame size, ethnicity, age-related changes, or athletic build. A healthy weight calculator should therefore be treated as a starting point for context, not as a strict verdict on what a person should weigh.